Shagun Parihar Controversy: Are Political Leaders Revealing Their Double Standards?
Shagun Parihar Controversy: Are Political Leaders Revealing Their Double Standards?
- Nov 21, 2026
- 0
- 6 minutes read
If demanding accountability today is a democratic right, then questioning the events of yesterday is equally important. Selective sensitivity and convenient silence can never be substitutes for the truth.
BY Ramneek Manhas
The controversy surrounding BJP MLA Shagun Parihar in Kishtwar has sparked a major political debate in Jammu and Kashmir. What began as the martyrdom of two Special Police Officers (SPOs) has gradually escalated into a political confrontation involving the BJP, National Conference, and Congress. However, beyond political arguments and accusations, the controversy raises fundamental questions about democratic rights, historical truth, and the responsibility of political leadership.
Shagun Parihar has raised serious concerns about the security situation in Kishtwar and questioned the functioning of the administration and police. Having lost her father and uncle to militancy, her concerns deserve to be heard with sensitivity and seriousness. As a respected citizen and an elected member of the Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly, she has every democratic right to question the security system, seek answers and demand accountability, particularly on matters concerning public safety and justice for victims.
I also spoke with Shagun Parihar regarding the ongoing controversy. During our conversation, she stated, “The videos speak for themselves, and my statement was based on the feedback and reactions of local people.” She further pointed out that the incident and related evidence are already in the public domain. Therefore, it would be unfair to label her remarks as communal or baseless without first examining the facts and available evidence. It appears that she was merely reiterating the allegations made by local residents.
She also expressed concern over the political response to the issue, stating, “Unfortunately, the National Conference and the Congress Party, instead of addressing their failures on various fronts and focusing on people’s real issues, seem more interested in creating controversies and confusing the public. Such political debates only divert attention from genuine concerns that deserve public attention and serious discussion.”
Picking a phrase out of context and magnifying it into a controversy is an age-old diversionary tactic.
My simple question to those creating a political uproar over her statement regarding alleged announcements from mosques: Do any of them have the courage to remind the new generation about the horrific and dark history of Jammu and Kashmir, when threats were issued from mosques targeting Kashmiri Hindus?
“Raliv, Tsaliv or Galiv”—meaning convert, leave Kashmir, or be prepared to die. These words are deeply etched in the collective memory of displaced Kashmiri Hindus. Targeted killings, open threats, and a terrifying atmosphere of terror forced an entire community to abandon their birthplace, ancestral land, home, and everything.
The erstwhile Doda district, which included Bhaderwah, Doda, Kishtwar and Ramban, also witnessed the disturbing period of terror, violence, killings and massacres. During the mid-1990s, communal and threatening slogans were raised from mosques in parts of the region as a matter of routine. Many of us witnessed that dark period firsthand. Will those questioning such historical references today deny this harsh reality?
That period was a horrific tragedy, not just for one community but for the entire region. In that wave of violence and terror, people belonging to different religious communities suffered the loss of lives and property, and countless families saw their lives changed forever.
Exposing the truth is not communalism, and questioning the security system is not a crime. Ironically, some people are troubled by statements made today but remain reluctant to discuss the bitter and dark chapters of the past that cannot be erased from collective memory. History cannot be accepted or rejected according to one’s convenience. If demanding accountability today is a democratic right, then questioning the events of yesterday is equally important. Selective sensitivity and convenient silence can never be substitutes for the truth.
However, the same standards of responsibility must apply to every political leader, irrespective of party or position. This brings us to the statements made by Congress leader and J&K Pradesh Congress Committee president Tariq Hameed Karra regarding the killing of the two SPOs in Kishtwar.
Karra initially presented a tall tale suggesting that the two SPOs, who were reportedly returning from a hunting expedition in civilian clothes, might have been mistaken for militants by Army personnel, who allegedly opened fire on them. He referred to the possibility that the Army patrol had changed between the time the SPOs passed through security checkpoints while heading towards the forest and their return. This was a serious suggestion that directly raised the possibility of Army personnel being responsible for their deaths. Is this conspiracy theory not an attempt to whitewash the actions of terrorists while maligning the security forces?
However, in a damage control exercise following severe criticism, Karra reiterated that he had never accused the army, but had merely suggested that all possible angles, including those involving militants and the army, be investigated.
Of course, an impartial investigation should be conducted to establish the truth and fix responsibility, if required. Nobody is above scrutiny, including the Army and the Police. But the real question is: why would a senior political leader publicly present such a specific theory implicating Army personnel and subsequently retreat by claiming that he had never accused the Army?
Demanding an investigation is one thing; presenting an unverified theory involving the Army is quite another. Such serious allegations, particularly concerning national security and the deaths of serving police personnel, should not be floated on speculation or unverified political inputs. If there is credible evidence, it must be presented before the appropriate investigating authorities. Responsible leadership demands restraint, facts and accountability—not contradictory statements that can create unnecessary mistrust between security institutions.
Ultimately, the people of Jammu and Kashmir deserve truth, justice and responsible leadership. The pain of the past must neither be forgotten nor exploited, and the security concerns of the present must neither be dismissed nor politicides. We cannot build a peaceful future by selectively remembering history, questioning some institutions while shielding others, or treating political convenience as a substitute for facts.
History deserves honesty, security demands accountability, and democracy demands responsibility. No political leader should be allowed to manipulate any of these for narrow political gains.
The author is a senior journalist and editor of J&K Reporter. He holds a bachelor’s degree in Mass Communication, specializing in Writing and Reporting, and has 25 years of experience in journalism.